Tulane University
- Center For Global Development
- Center For Global Education
- Center For Inter-american Policy And Research
- Central America
- Child Health
- Children's Literature
- Cuba Abroad
- Cuba Embargo
- Cuba-us Relations
- Cuban & Caribbean S
- Cuban & Caribbean Studies
- Cuban Ambassador
- Cuban And Caribbean Studies Institute
- Cuban Artists
- Cuban Film
- Cuban Heritage Collection
- Cuban Theater
- Cuban-american
- Day Of The Dead
- Declining Inequality
- Declining Inequality In Latin America
- Delgado
- Democracy
- Development
- Diaspora
- Disaster Relief
- Disaster Resilience Leadership Academy
- Diversity
- Dominican Republic
- Doris Stone Librarian And Director
- General Latin America
- Glick Fellowship
- Global Development
- Globalization
- Graduate Conference
- Graduate Research
- Graduate Student Conference
- Graduate Students
- Gran Fiesta
- Grants & Fellowships
- Greenleaf
- Greenleaf Fellow
- Indigenous Latin American Languages
- Inequality
- Inter-american Relations
- International Health & Development
- International Programs
- International Relations
- Lasa
- Lasa 2010
- Latin America
- Latin American Library
- Latin American Studies
- Latin Americanist Graduate Association
- Mexican Cultural Institute
- Mexico
- Mexico-u.s. Border
- Miami
- Middle America
- Middle American Research Institute
- Natural Disasters
- Neoliberalism
- New Oreleans
- New Orleans
- New Orleans Center For The Gulf South
- New Orleans Film Festival
- Santiago De Cuba
- School Of Architecture
- School Of Law
- School Of Liberal Arts
- School Of Public Health & Tropical Medicine
- School Of Public Health And Tropical Medicine
- School Of Science & Engineering
- School Of Social Work
- Semester Abroad
- Sexuality
- Slave Rebellion
- Slave Trade
- Staff
- State-society Relations
- Stone Center
- Stone Center For Latin American Studies
- Stone Center Summer Abroad
- Student Funding
- (120) Cuba
- (62) Caribbean
- (46) General Latin America
- (42) Haiti
- (30) Cuban & Caribbean Studies
- (29) New Wave
- (14) Art
- (14) Future Of Cuba
- (14) Music
- (13) Cuba-us Relations
- (13) Stone Center For Latin American Studies
- (12) Study Abroad
- (12) South America
- (12) Literature
- (11) Latin America
- (11) Core Faculty
- (10) Community
- (10) Puerto Rico
- (6) Slavery
- (6) School Of Public Health And Tropical Medicine
- (6) Immigration
- (6) Spanish & Portuguese
- (6) Jamaica
- (6) Art History
- (6) North America
- (5) Hispanic Heritage Month
- (5) African Diaspora
- (5) Social Justice
- (5) Venezuela
- (5) Environment
- (5) Public Health In Cuba
- (5) Social Policy
- (5) Architecture
- (5) Greenleaf Fellows
- (4) Colombia
- (4) Events
- (4) Center For Inter-american Policy And Research
- (4) Social Work
- (4) Political Science
- (4) Tulane
- (4) Socialism
- (4) Food And Culture
- (4) Graduate Conference
- (4) Summer Study Abroad
- (4) Law
- (3) Photo Competition
- (3) Political Economy
- (3) Environmental Studies
- (3) Identity
- (3) Spanish
- (3) Coffee
- (3) Performance
- (3) Performing Arts
- (3) A.b. Freedman School Of Business
- (3) Language
- (3) Slave Trade
- (3) Graduate Students
- (3) Honduras
- (3) Immigrants
- (3) Politics Of Migration
- (3) Africana Studies
- (3) Revolution
- (3) School Of Social Work
- (3) Pebbles Center
- (3) Mesoamerica
- (3) Louisiana
- (3) Book Talk
- (3) Exhibitions
- (3) Reading Project
- (3) Film Studies
- (3) Symposium
- (3) Community Events
- (2) Social Movements
- (2) Archive
- (2) New Orleans Film Festival
- (2) Graduate Research
- (2) Diversity
- (2) Cuban Artists
- (2) Haitian Revolution
- (2) Lasa
- (2) Foreign Policy
- (2) Urban History
- (2) Urban Planning
- (2) Middle American Research Institute
- (2) Us-mexico Border
- (2) Study In Latin America
- (2) Student Funding
- (2) Spanish America
- (2) Linguistics
- (2) Afro-caribbean Religion
- (2) Language And Culture
- (2) Museum
- (2) Hurricane
- (2) Critical Race Theory
- (2) Black History Month
- (2) Cuban And Caribbean Studies Institute
- (2) Lasa 2010
- (2) Newcomb
- (2) Celebración Latina
- (2) International Programs
- (2) Poetry
- (2) Festivals
- (2) Affiliated Faculty
- (2) Caribbean Literature
- (2) West Indies
- (2) Exhibition
- (2) France
- (2) Inter-american Relations
- (2) Teacher Workshop
- (2) Ecology & Evolutionary Biology
- (2) Postcolonial Studies
- (2) Curriculum Unit
- (2) Travel
- (2) Greenleaf
- (2) Jazz
- (2) Undergraduate Conference
- (2) Human Development
- (2) Film Series
- (2) Staff
- (2) Celebracion Latina
- (1) Social Conflict
- (1) Social Studies
- (1) Non-profit
- (1) Indigenous Latin American Languages
- (1) Hurricane Katrina
- (1) Environmental Governance
- (1) Southern Cone
- (1) K-12 Cuba Teacher Institute
- (1) Commitment To Equity
- (1) French
- (1) Lgbtqa+
- (1) Fundraising
- (1) Office Of Multicultural Affairs
- (1) Contemporary Arts Center
- (1) International Students
- (1) Chile
- (1) K-12 Teacher Workshop
- (1) Audubon Zoo
- (1) Oliver Houck
- (1) Afro Latinos
- (1) Foodways
- (1) Social Inclusion
- (1) Cuban & Caribbean S
- (1) Trauma Institute
- (1) Graduate Student Conference
- (1) City
- (1) Maya Symposium
- (1) Belize
- (1) Disaster Resilience Leadership Academy
- (1) Afro-brazilian
- (1) Lago Conference
- (1) U.s.-cuban Relations
- (1) Children's Literature
- (1) Migrant
- (1) Declining Inequality
- (1) Declining Inequality In Latin America
- (1) Immigrant
- (1) Day Of The Dead
- (1) Mexico-u.s. Border
- (1) Colonialism
- (1) Latin Americanist Graduate Association
- (1) Colonial Era
- (1) Undergraduate
- (1) Teacher Workshop; Outreach
- (1) Mexican Consulate
- (1) Police Violence
- (1) Mexican Cultural Institute
- (1) Globalization
- (1) Greenleaf Fellow
- (1) Global Development
- (1) Social Equity
- (1) New Orleans Center For The Gulf South
- (1) Africa
- (1) Cimafunk
- (1) Writing
- (1) Carnaval
- (1) New Orleans Jazz Museum
- (1) Stone Center Summer Abroad
- (1) Language Learning
- (1) Gran Fiesta
- (1) Festival
- (1) Centenarios
- (1) Reception
- (1) Stone Center
- (1) Greenleaf Fellowship Program
- (1) Nola
- (1) Christian Science Monitor
- (1) Grants & Fellowships
- (1) Peru
- (1) Natural Disasters
- (1) Hip Hop
- (1) Guitar
- (1) School Of Law
- (1) Trinidad & Tobago
- (1) Bahamas
- (1) Asia
- (1) Vietnam
- (1) School Of Public Health & Tropical Medicine
- (1) International Health & Development
- (1) The Latin American Library
- (1) Doris Stone Librarian And Director
- (1) School Of Architecture
- (1) Emeritus Faculty
- (1) French & Italian
- (1) Tulanian
- (1) Associate Professor
- (1) Europe
- (1) School Of Science & Engineering
- (1) Theatre & Dance
- (1) Haitian Creole
- (1) Tropical Medicine
- (1) Neoliberalism
- (1) Job Opportunity
- (1) Title Vi
- (1) Maternal Health
- (1) Santiago De Cuba
- (1) Payson Center
- (1) Trade
- (1) Social Entrepreneurship
- (1) Child Health
- (1) Researcher
- (1) Indigenous Languages
- (1) Miami
- (1) Cuban Heritage Collection
- (1) Cipr Post-doctoral Fellowship
- (1) Glick Fellowship
- (1) U.s.
- (1) President Obama
On Immigration, Facts, and Chaos and Lawlessness
In his 8/31/16 speech on immigration, Donald Trump suggested there is a direct, causal link between “illegal immigration” and violent crime, social security and Medicare abuse, unemployment and low wages, and outright “chaos and lawlessness”. As appealing as that might seem for those in need of a convenient scapegoat, the evidence is arrayed against it.
Start with Mr. Trump’s counterfactual: “Countless Americans who have died in recent years would be alive today if not for the open border policies of this administration.” His causal factor—the alleged open border policy—is problematic given the facts. The number of border agents has quintupled in the last eighteen years and, as a result, apprehensions at the border have plummeted to a mere fraction of what they were in 2000. Lower employment opportunities in a weaker U.S. economy have undoubtedly diminished the pull for migrants. But more stringent immigration enforcement has also been a factor. Deportations, the do-all and end-all of Mr. Trump’s proposal, are at an all-time high under President Obama, so much so that he is under fire from liberals for his deportation record.
The loss of lives to violent crime is a tragedy, and crimes are committed by individuals that are present in our communities. From the fact that some are immigrants we cannot infer that all immigrants are criminals. In fact, while it is notoriously difficult to obtain credible data, studies repeatedly show that immigrants have significantly lower crime rates than the native-born. Since immigrants who commit crimes are likely to be deported they have a greater incentive to be prudent: they have more to lose from breaking the law. Interestingly, second-generation migrants have crime rates that approximate those of the general population, which suggests that their criminal involvement rises with assimilation, an avowed goal of Mr. Trump’s policy.
People who emigrate tend to be motivated and ambitious, searching for better lives. Do they find them by reducing “jobs and wages for American workers”? The impact of low-skilled migration—legal or not—on wages is much more highly contested than Mr. Trumpâ’‘¬’“¢s assertions would suggest. At the very least, no simple causal relation exists between immigration and wages. Much depends on whether migrants and local workers substitute or complement each other, the impact that new arrivals have on older migrants, and the context of the local economy. By most estimates the impact of migration on local wages is likely to be modest, with some studies even suggesting it might be positive.
Lost in Mr. Trump’s portrayal of immigrants is the fact that they are a boon to the receiving communities. A recent article in the Economist cites a study showing that a 2007 crackdown on illegal migrants in Arizona actually shrank its economy by 2%. Immigrants can, and in many cases do create jobs, help drive innovation, and make the locals more prosperous. They do not “draw much more out from the system than they will ever pay in”. “Illegal workers”, as Mr. Trump calls them, are generally ineligible for most federal public benefits programs, including the vilified Affordable Care Act. In point of fact, undocumented workers pay into the system by using false social security numbers, which means they will never collect the benefits—the opposite of what Mr. Trump asserts. Even lawful permanent residents must wait at least five years before they are eligible for benefits, and when they are eligible, studies show that they use benefits at lower rates and with a lower average value of benefits per recipient than the native-born.
Illegal migration is a symptom of a dysfunctional immigration regime which clearly requires comprehensive reform. But attributing our social and economic woes to it where the facts do not warrant it is disingenuous and, in the present context, demagogic.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Ludovico Feoli
Permanent Researcher and CEO, CIAPA, Executive Director - Center for Inter-American Policy and Research at Tulane University
BLOG AUTHORS & RECENT POSTS
Nora Lustig
Elections in America: It is also about rising equality November 25th, 2016
Ludovico Feoli
On Immigration, Facts, and Chaos and Lawlessness September 5th, 2016
Punching Above Your Weight in International Affairs October 17th, 2014
Political Party Fragmentation: A Pejorative Term? June 13th, 2014
Elections and Democracy in Central America March 20th, 2014
El preocupante panorama de la estabilidad democrática en Centroamérica July 25th, 2013
Rules That Bind Us January 10th, 2013
What Can We Conclude From the Cartagena Summit? April 18th, 2012
School Vouchers: What Louisiana can Learn from Chile March 15th, 2012
Key Issues for the Latin American Region in 2012 February 10th, 2012
National Intelligence Threat Assessment and Latin America February 2nd, 2012
Transparency and Accountability in Legislatures January 11th, 2012
LATEST SITE UPDATES
EVENTS
- A New Political Uprising: Perspectives on Haitian Current Events
- Criminal Leviathans: How Gangs Govern, Organize Crime, and Threaten the State from Behind Bars
- "The Cuban Economy: Performance, Problems, and Prospects" with Dr. Paolo Spadoni
- Canceled: "Brazil in the 21st Century" event with Dr. Idelber Avelar and Sergio Moro
- Perspectives on Latin America
- Spring Series: Now on Zoom
NEWS
- Research Group MEGA Held Virtual Workshop
- Tulane Sociology Professor Featured in Washington Post Op-Ed about Trump-Era Policy Impacts in Venezuela
- The CEQ Institute Entered Into A Fiscal Analysis Partnership With The Millennium Challenge Corporation
- Health Equity Network of the Americas
- CIPR Announces Inter-American Policy and Research Fellowship
- Challenges posed by the COVID-19 pandemic in the health of women, children, and adolescents in Latin America and the Caribbean
- 2020-2021 CIPR Post-Doctoral Fellows
- Catholic Church urges Venezuela to unite against coronavirus
- The new inequalities and people-to-people social protection
- What should Venezuela do about COVID-19? (in Spanish)
MEDIA
- Left Parties, Weak Courts, and Women Justices in Latin America
- Academia de Centroamérica: Consecuencias económicas y políticas del cambio de gobierno en los Estados Unidos
- Book Talk: Seeds of Power: Environmental Injustice and Genetically Modified Soybeans in Argentina
PEOPLE

Copyright © 2021 CIPR | Center For Inter-American Policy & Research All Rights Reserved.
Tulane University, 205 Richardson Building, New Orleans, LA 70118, (504) 862-3141 cipr@tulane.edu